GVBCH Constitution: Proposed Amendments
Proposed by the Constitution Committee: Sid Boswell, Chris Nygren, Kathy VanDyke
Base text: GVBCH Constitution adopted November 18, 2012
Presented: general meeting, Thursday, November 19, 2026
Vote: December meeting, Saturday, December 19, 2026
Marked copy: the 2012 constitution with every change below shown as a tracked change
The constitution has not been revised since 2012. At its May 21 meeting the Board charged this committee with adding electronic voting and making other needed changes, with a membership vote before the end of the year. The committee agrees on everything below and has checked the changes for consistency with the Back Country Horsemen of Montana constitution.
These are eleven separate amendments, each voted on its own, so a disagreement over one does not hold up the rest.
- Housekeeping and corrections
- Board action between meetings (electronic voting)
- Presiding when the President and Vice President are both absent
- Proxy limits and quorum counting
- Board vacancies near the end of a term
- Nominating committee
- Board quorum
- Term limits for President and Vice President only
- President’s quarterly audit
- Duplicate expulsion section
- Canceling a meeting for weather or emergency
Amendment 1: Housekeeping and corrections
What it does: fixes typos, broken cross-references, a numbering error, capitalization, punctuation and grammar in the 2012 text. No change in meaning. One motion.
Proposed motion: Correct capitalization, punctuation, spelling, grammar, numbering and cross-references throughout the constitution, without change in meaning, as shown in the marked copy.
The specific corrections:
- Article II, Section 5 refers to “Article lll, Section 4” for the quorum. Correct to Article III, Section 5. (Section 4 is Board Meetings.) If Amendment 7 is adopted, this cross-reference is removed instead, because the quorum is then stated in the same Section.
- Article V, Section 5 refers to “ARITCLE X, Section 2” for petty cash. Correct to Article XI, Section 2. (Article X is Amendments.)
- Article VIII, Section 2 refers to “Article 111, Sections 6.” Correct to Article III, Section 6.
- Article VII skips Section 5, running 1, 2, 3, 4, then 6. Renumber Section 6 as Section 5.
- The heading reads “ARCTICLE IV.” Correct to ARTICLE IV.
- Article V, Section 3 says the Vice President may “do-sign” checks. Correct to co-sign.
- Article XIII calls the organization the “Gallatin Valley Back Country Club.” Correct to Gallatin Valley Back Country Horsemen.
- Article XI, Section 1 reads “will thereby enjoin no political donations” and ends in a comma. Correct to “will therefore make no political donations” and end the sentence with a period.
- Article headings and references typed with lowercase L’s or Arabic numerals: “ARTICLE l,” “ARTICLE lll,” “ARTICLE 1.” Correct to I, III and Article I.
- Grammar, no change in meaning: “various member of the general public” to members; “funds of the organizations” to organization; “a written account of which shall be open” to a written account which shall be open; “special meetings of the organization of its Board” to or its Board; “Director Is a current member” to is; “more than (3) consecutive terms” to three (3); “State of Director meeting” to a State Board of Directors meeting; “State Board of Director” to State Board Director; “All Officers and Board of Directors shall serve” to All Officers and Directors; “Director’s vacancies” to Director vacancies; “Roberts Rules of Order” to Robert’s Rules of Order; dashes used as punctuation in the membership categories replaced with a comma, semicolon or period; “(GVBCH) club Board of Directors” to GVBCH Board of Directors.
- Capitalization: capitals are kept only for proper names (the organization, Back Country Horsemen of Montana and of America, Robert’s Rules of Order, the State Convention), the offices and bodies this constitution creates (President, Vice President, Secretary, Treasurer, Past President, Officers, Directors, Board, State Board Directors, Alternate, Nominating Committee, Appellate Tribunal), membership category labels, references to Articles and Sections, headings, months, and the first word of a sentence. Everything else is lowercased, for example “a Vacancy,” “reputable Financial Institution,” “the December General Meeting,” “Election Ballots,” “the Newsletter,” “Chapter Members,” “Board Action.” One correction goes the other way: “Members of the year” becomes Members of the Year, the chapter’s award, and “The secretary” becomes The Secretary. Every instance is marked in the marked copy.
- Section headings: “Section 5 Quorums” in Article II is missing its colon. Add it.
Amendment 2: Board action between meetings
What it does: lets the Board vote by e-mail, mail or other electronic means between regular Board meetings. This is the electronic voting the committee was formed to add.
Current text: none. Add a new Article III, Section 7.
Proposed text:
Section 7: Action Without a Meeting
Between regular Board meetings, the Board of Directors may act by mail, e-mail, or other electronic communication, provided that:
- The proposal is initiated by the President or by any three (3) Officers and/or Directors.
- Notice stating the exact proposal to be acted upon is sent to every voting Board member at his or her last known e-mail address, mailing address, or phone number.
- Voting Board members are given not less than three (3) days from the sending of notice in which to respond.
- The proposal passes only upon the affirmative vote of a majority of all voting Board members then in office, whether or not all respond.
- The Secretary records the proposal, the vote of each Board member, and the result in the minutes of the next regular Board meeting.
Proxy representation shall not apply to action taken under this Section; each voting Board member votes directly. This Section shall not be used to remove an Officer or Director, to expel a member, or to amend this constitution.
Why:
- Today the constitution has no way for the Board to act between meetings. Robert’s Rules, our final authority under Article XIV, does not allow voting outside a meeting unless the bylaws authorize it. The only option now is calling a special meeting.
- The state organization already allows this. BCHMT Constitution Article VII, Section 6 lets the State Board act “by mail, email, electronic communication, or phone, provided that each director receives notice of the proposal.”
- This version adds three safeguards the state’s does not have: a minimum response time, a majority of the whole Board to pass (not just those who reply), and a record in the minutes.
- Removals, expulsions and amendments stay in the meeting room, where members can be heard.
- This covers Board action only. It does not change how members vote or attend general meetings.
Amendment 3: Presiding when the President and Vice President are both absent
What it does: fills the empty Article V, Section 6 with the duties of Directors and the immediate Past President, and says who runs a meeting when the President and Vice President are both absent.
Current text (Article V, Section 6):
Section 6: Directors and Past President Omitted from past versions
Proposed text:
Section 6: Directors and Immediate Past President
Directors shall attend meetings of the Board and of the organization, shall represent the interests of the membership, shall serve on committees as appointed, and shall perform such other duties as the Board may assign.
The immediate Past President shall serve as an ex officio voting member of the Board and shall advise the President and the Board on the practices and prior actions of the organization.
Should both the President and the Vice President be absent from a meeting of the organization or of the Board, the Secretary shall call the meeting to order and shall immediately conduct an election of a President Pro Tem from among the members present and eligible to vote at that meeting. The President Pro Tem shall preside through adjournment and shall hold no authority of the office beyond that meeting. Should the Secretary also be absent, any member present and eligible to vote may call the meeting to order for that purpose, and the body shall then elect a Secretary Pro Tem to record the minutes.
Proxy representation confers the right to vote only. A proxy holder shall not preside.
Why:
- Article V stops at the Vice President. When both are out, as at the August 20 meeting, the constitution does not say who opens the meeting.
- Robert’s Rules would get to the same answer, but members should not have to look it up to run a meeting.
- The Directors’ section has been blank since at least 2012.
Amendment 4: Proxy limits and quorum counting
What it does: limits each member to holding one proxy at a Board meeting, and makes clear that quorum counts people in the room.
Current text (Article III, Section 6):
Voting Board members may appoint any members in good standing to serve as proxy representation for the purpose of voting at Board meetings. It is the responsibility of the Board member to obtain proxy representation. If the Board member fails to attend or obtain proxy representation, then the Board member shall be considered absent from the meeting.
Proposed addition at the end:
No member shall hold more than one (1) proxy at any Board meeting. For the purpose of determining a quorum under Section 5, each person physically present shall be counted once, regardless of the number of votes that person is entitled to cast.
Why:
- Today there is no limit. One person could hold several proxies and cast a large share of the Board’s votes.
- It is unclear whether a person holding a proxy counts as one toward the Board quorum of eight, or two. The second sentence settles it: one.
- The committee considered keeping only the quorum-counting sentence and chose to include the one-proxy limit as well.
Amendment 5: Board vacancies near the end of a term
What it does: lets the Board leave a vacant seat open when little time remains in the term.
Current text (Article IV, Section 3):
Any vacancy or vacancies in any office or in the Board of Directors shall be filled by the Board of Directors for the balance of such term, with the exception of President, which will automatically be filled by the Vice President.
Proposed text (addition in bold):
Any vacancy or vacancies in any office or in the Board of Directors shall be filled by the Board of Directors for the balance of such term, with the exception of President, which will automatically be filled by the Vice President. Provided, that where fewer than six (6) months remain in the term, the Board may by majority vote leave the seat vacant until the next regular election.
Why:
- “Shall be filled” is mandatory. Today the Board has no choice, even when a seat opens a few weeks before the December election.
- Six months puts the cutoff around the June meeting. A seat that opens in the second half of the year can wait for the election; anything earlier gets filled.
- The Board may still fill the seat. This only removes the requirement.
Amendment 6: Nominating committee
What it does: changes the nominating committee’s charge to match what the chapter actually does.
Current text (Article VI, Section 1, October step):
October: A Nominating Committee shall be appointed for the purpose of nominating three (3) suitable candidates for each of the organization’s Offices.
Proposed text:
October: A Nominating Committee shall be appointed for the purpose of nominating at least one (1) suitable candidate for each of the organization’s offices, and additional candidates where available.
Why:
- The chapter has not nominated three candidates per office, and realistically cannot. As written, we are out of compliance with our own constitution every October.
- Nominations from the floor stay open in November, as today.
Amendment 7: Board quorum
What it does: replaces the fixed Board quorum of eight with a majority of the Board members in office, says plainly who counts, and gives each quorum its own heading: the general-meeting quorum sits with the voting rules in Article II, and the Board quorum stands alone in Article III. The general-meeting quorum of twelve does not change.
Current text (Article II, Section 5):
Section 5 Quorums
A voting membership is considered in ‘good standing’ providing membership dues are paid in full to date. A simple majority of members in good standing, voting when the organization is in session at a regular or special meeting, shall be required to conduct that business requiring group action, providing a quorum (see Article lll, Section 4) is present, and except for removal of Officers and/or Directors which is provided herein.
Current text (Article III, Section 5):
Section 5: Quorums
Twelve (12) voting members in good standing shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of business at any regular or special meeting of this organization. Eight (8) voting members in good standing shall constitute a quorum for a meeting of the Board of Directors.
Proposed text (Article II, Section 5). The twelve-member sentence moves here word for word, in bold, and the cross-reference is no longer needed:
Section 5: Voting and Quorum
A voting membership is considered in ‘good standing’ providing membership dues are paid in full to date. Twelve (12) voting members in good standing shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of business at any regular or special meeting of this organization. A simple majority of members in good standing, voting when the organization is in session at a regular or special meeting, shall be required to conduct that business requiring group action, providing a quorum is present, and except for removal of Officers and/or Directors which is provided herein.
Proposed text (Article III, Section 5):
Section 5: Board Quorum
A majority of the voting members of the Board of Directors then in office shall constitute a quorum for a meeting of the Board of Directors. The voting members of the Board are the Officers, the Directors, and the immediate Past President as provided in Article IV, Section 2. A State Board Director shall not be counted unless that Director also holds an office or a directorship. No person shall be counted more than once toward a quorum, regardless of the number of positions held or proxies carried.
Why:
- Eight is close to the whole Board. The Board is eleven seats when full: four Officers, six Directors, and the immediate Past President. Eight of eleven is 73 percent, and with a vacant seat and one person holding two positions, the count in August and September was nine people, so eight was 89 percent of the people who existed. The Board made quorum with exactly eight in August, September and October.
- A fixed number does not follow the Board. Every vacancy raises the real percentage needed. “A majority of those then in office” moves with the roster and cannot be outrun by resignations.
- It settles the three counting questions that the current text leaves open: the Past President is in, State Board Directors are out unless separately seated, and one person counts once.
- Eight is also higher than the state organization requires of itself and higher than Robert’s Rules supplies by default, which is a majority.
- Two Sections are both headed “Quorums” today, and the one in Article II never states a quorum. After this amendment the general-meeting quorum is in Article II with the voting rules, and Article III, Section 5 covers the Board only.
What the new number would be: 6 of the 10 seats filled today. 5 of 9 if a seat falls vacant. 6 of 11 with a full Board and a separate Past President.
The committee considered “half plus one” in place of a majority. The two are the same on an even Board and differ only on an odd one (6 of 9 instead of 5). The committee chose a majority, the conventional wording.
Amendment 8: Term limits for President and Vice President only
What it does: keeps the three-term limit for the President and Vice President and removes it for the Secretary and Treasurer.
Current text (Article VII, Section 4):
No Officer shall hold the same office for more than (3) consecutive terms. There shall be no limit for service by Directors.
Proposed text (with Amendment 1’s correction of “(3)”):
No President or Vice President shall hold the same office for more than three (3) consecutive terms. There shall be no limit for service by the Secretary, the Treasurer or Directors.
Why:
- Term limits keep the leadership roles turning over. The President and Vice President set the chapter’s direction, so the limit stays for them.
- The Secretary and Treasurer are continuity jobs. Keeping the minutes, the roster, the books and the bank signatures in the same hands year to year is an advantage, and both jobs are hard to fill. Directors already have no limit.
- The Treasurer’s work is still checked: a written financial report every month and books open to any member in good standing (Article V, Section 5), and an annual audit by a committee of three Board members (Article XI, Section 3).
- The chapter has not been following the limit. Jim Wing was Treasurer four years running (2020 through 2023 newsletters).
Timing matters: our current Secretary has served since 2024, so 2027 would be a fourth consecutive term, which the current text bars. Amendments take effect when adopted, so on December 19 the amendment votes must come before the elections for this to apply to the 2027 slate.
Amendment 9: President’s quarterly audit
What it does: removes the requirement that the President audit the Treasurer’s books every quarter. The annual audit stays.
Current text (Article V, Section 2, last sentence):
He/She will conduct a Quarterly audit of the Treasurer’s books.
Proposed text: delete the sentence. The rest of Section 2 is unchanged.
Why:
- The quarterly audit has fallen out of practice, and the Board does not receive quarterly audit reports. As written, we are out of compliance with our own constitution every quarter.
- The books are checked without it. The Treasurer gives a written financial report every month and keeps the books open to any member in good standing (Article V, Section 5). A committee of three Board members audits the books every year (Article XI, Section 3).
- An audit by a committee of three is a better check than an audit by one officer.
If this amendment is not adopted, the sentence stays, with “Quarterly” lowercased under Amendment 1.
Amendment 10: Duplicate expulsion section
What it does: deletes Article II, Section 4, which repeats Article XIV, Section 4, and renumbers the Section after it. The grounds and the procedure for expelling a member do not change.
Current text (Article II, Section 4):
Section 4: Expulsion
Chapter Members may be expelled by the procedure in Article XIV, Section 4 for conduct which is intimidating, threatening, pugnacious, belligerent or otherwise harmful to members of the chapter or which impairs the functioning or damages the reputation of the chapter.
Proposed text: delete Article II, Section 4. Renumber Article II, Section 5 as Section 4.
Why:
- Article XIV, Section 4 states the same grounds in the same words, then sets out the whole procedure: an investigating committee, notice, a hearing, a two-thirds vote, and an appeal. Article II, Section 4 adds nothing to it.
- Every protection a member has today is in Article XIV, Section 4, and it stays exactly as it is.
- One rule written in two places can drift apart the next time either is amended.
If this amendment is not adopted, Article II, Section 4 stays, with “Chapter Members” lowercased to “Chapter members” under Amendment 1.
Amendment 11: Canceling a meeting for weather or emergency
What it does: says who may cancel or postpone a meeting for weather or another emergency, and makes the Board’s monthly meeting requirement allow for it.
Current text (Article III, Section 1):
Notice shall be given of all meetings or meeting cancellations. Written notice including publications and/or e-mail shall be sent to the entire membership at least three (3) days prior to any special meetings.
Proposed text (addition in bold):
Notice shall be given of all meetings or meeting cancellations. Written notice including publications and/or e-mail shall be sent to the entire membership at least three (3) days prior to any special meetings. The President, or the Vice President in the President’s absence, may cancel or postpone any meeting because of weather or other emergency.
Current text (Article III, Section 4, first sentence):
Board meetings shall be held at the convenience of a majority of the Directors, and shall meet at least once a month.
Proposed text (changes in bold):
Board meetings shall be held at the convenience of a majority of the Directors, and the Board shall meet at least once a month, unless the meeting is canceled under Section 1.
The rest of Section 4 is unchanged.
Why:
- “Shall meet at least once a month” has no exception. When a snowstorm canceled the April meetings, the constitution did not allow for it.
- Section 1 already requires notice of “meeting cancellations,” so the constitution expects them. It never says who may cancel a meeting or why.
- The requirement stays. The Board still must meet every month; only weather or another emergency excuses a meeting.
- A cancellation cannot be used to keep the Board or the members from meeting. Any three Officers or Directors, or ten voting members, can still call a special meeting under Section 3, and under Amendment 2 the Board can act by e-mail in the meantime.
- It covers general meetings as well as Board meetings.
How the amendments get adopted
Article X requires the amendments to be presented at a regular meeting, written notice to the membership before the vote, a quorum present, and a two-thirds vote.
- Thursday, November 19: the committee presents the amendments at the general meeting.
- December 1 newsletter: the full text of the amendments, as the written notice to members.
- Saturday, December 19, Christmas party and December meeting: amendment votes first, then elections, so Amendment 8 applies to this year’s slate. Twelve voting members must be present in the room. Each amendment is voted on separately and needs two-thirds in favor.
Where amendments touch the same text: Amendments 1 and 7 both touch the cross-reference in Article II, Section 5; Amendments 1 and 9 both touch the audit sentence; Amendments 1 and 10 both touch Article II, Section 4. In each case the later amendment controls if it is adopted, and Amendment 1’s correction applies if it is not. If Amendment 10 is adopted, the Section that Amendment 7 calls Article II, Section 5 becomes Article II, Section 4.
gvbch-constitution-as-amended Download
gvbch-constitution-as-amended docx Download